Skip to main content
6:00 am
>> this week on the journal, editorial report. a stunning upset this delaware has some democrats celebrating. is that voter uprising headed straight for them. and it's democrat versus democrat on capitol hill as more of the rank and file break with party leaders over plans to raise taxes on upper incomes. plus, chris christie's pension fight. the unions are howling after new jersey's governor unveils his plans to save a system that is only 46 billion dollars in the red. welcome to the journal, editorial report, i'm paul gigot. tea party candidate christine
6:01 am
o'donnell's stunning victory tuesday over long time republican congressman mike castle has many on the left celebrating. and crowing about a republican civil war. well, democrats may keep that senate seat as a result, but is the wave of voter anger that swept castle out now headed right toward them? join the panel this week, wall street journal columnist dan henning, kim strassel and steve moore. so, kim, i got an e-mail from john kerry one of the mass democratic e-mails basically almost doing cartwheels on my computer screen, celebrating the result in delaware. should they be that happy? >> i don't think they should because this was the last primary and right now, all the republicans that might get swept out or been swept out and the only people left to be swept out are democrats this fall. and a lot of the things that were driving the anger in
6:02 am
delaware that led to mike castle's loss there, had to do with the things that democrats have got problems on, too. i mean, he had a record, castle had a record people felt he wasn't good enough on fiscal responsibility. he voted for cap and trade. these are the hallmarks of the democratic party and these voters are now coming to get them. >> but does christine o'donnell have a chance to keep that seat or make over that seat for the republicans? because it would be a net pickup? >> yes, she does have a chance, paul, but certainly, mike castle would have had a better chance of winning. many' actually kind of happy with the outcome. i think that mike castle had been in the senate as a republican. he would have cut deals with, with barack obama on things like you know, cap and trade legislation, tax increases, on union issues and so, i have a sense that the republican voters want people really believe in the core issues and that's one of the reasons you've seen the upsets in
6:03 am
alaska, delaware, kentucky, nevada, i think the whole electorate has shifted to the right and agree with your premise, now you're going to see this hurricane that's hit the republican, i think it's headed right smack towards nancy pelosi and the democrats. >> paul: okay, if it's a difference this seat, delaware seat is the difference between only 49 republicans in the senate and 50 republicans or 51 in the senate where you have the ability to organize the senate, was it worth the trade? >> yeah, i think ultimately it was worth the trade. i agree with steve that the electorate looks like it's moving to the right, and the o'donnell victory is more a reflection of the anger of the electorate than of christine o'donnell. i'd like to make a point about this, paul. john kerry e-mail that you got, i read some of the commentary on the primaries and some of the liberal pundits, new york times editorial page, they're happy, proves that the republican party is drifting over to what ed rendell the governor of
6:04 am
pennsylvania called the crazyies. >> the nuts. >> the nuts. you know what? i'm beginning to think there is a risk here. in american politics you can be marginalized by the mainstream media. if the candidates do not-- or the tea partiers themselves do not start talking about what they actually stand for, independents will get nervous. the tea party eiers complaints are primarily economic. >> paul: they're fiscal, it's about spending, about the growth of government. since when are these radical ideas. >> they are not radical ideas and the criticism of the tea partiers by the liberal pundits never mention any of that. he think the burden is now on the tea party candidates and tea party representatives to start talking about economic issues. >> paul: well, kim, jim demint, the republican from south carolina who endorsed o'donnell at the end and sarah palin, do they have an obligation now to help her get across the finish line or can they just wash their hands of it and say, well, we conducted our intra party cleansing and
6:05 am
now you're on your own, ma'am? >> no, they absolutely do. you know, the way they're going to have to do this. here is the problem with some of the candidates. this election ought to be about democrats, their unpopular agenda and the problems that they've created for the country. the problem with some of these candidates is that they're just colorful enough that it allows the democrats to do what they want to do, which is to say, as dan said, say, these people are too crazy, don't worry about us, and what we do, these people are too crazy to give them the reins in washington. if jim demint and sarah palin and these guys are going to be successful they have to coach the candidates to get the focus bakken 0 the democrats and that's the only way they're going to win. >> paul: i have to tell you, i have not seen a single poll, steve, that shows that the republicans are out of step here this year. it seems that this is-- this argument, even the tea party argument seems to be directly where the independents are in this election. which is concerned with the state of the economy,
6:06 am
concerned with fiscal, with run away spending and fiscal issues. >> yeah, this is what the left doesn't understand, is that the tea partiers have become the mainstream or maybe the mainstream has become tea partiers, i've been out on the mall with uhundreds of thousands of people and it's a phenomena. i'm excited about the prospect of a senate next year with not just jim demint and tom coburn, but six or seven or eight more like history. as jim demint told me, the reinforcements are coming and that's a welcome thing if you're a conservative and believe in limited government. >> paul: take a look at wisconsin, hardly a right wing state. two democratic senators for 18 years, democratic governor for eight years yet, the republicans could sweep most of these, these state wide elections this year. what's going on in a state like that? >> well, it includes david
6:07 am
olby, elected in the 1960's chaerm of the appropriations committee. >> it's a toss up. a clear ago rasmussen did a poll, what people thought about congress. 58% said they would like to he think change the entire congress. that's a year ago and i think people have just become disgusted with the political class and they literally want the whole thing to start over again. and that's true in places like wisconsin, new jersey, california. this is a historic off year election, it really is. >> paul: 2006, 2008, republicans suffered that wave. >> yes. >> paul: and this time it looks like the democrats are going to be the party that takes the hit. when we come back forget this week's republican ballot in delaware, it's democrat versus democrat on capitol hill as more rank and file members br
6:08 am
glade lasting impressions. two complementary fragrances alternate to keep things... fresh day after day. and not just for 30 days -- but for 60. it's our longest-lasting plugins freshener. s.c. johnson. a family company. it beneful incredibites. ever sn anything like it? me neither. it's just the way you like it-- with carbohydrates for energy and protein for muscles. [ woman announcing ] beneful incredibites. another healthful, flavorful beneful.
6:09 am
6:10 am
let's take a look at the stats. mini has more than double the fiber and whole grain... ming him a great contender in thist... against mid-morning hunger. honey nut cheerios is coming in a littlehort. you've got more whole grain in your little finger! let's get ready for breakfaaaaaaaaaast! ( ding, cheering, ringing ) keeping you full and focused with more than double the fiber and whole grain... in every tasty bite -- frrrrrrosted mini-wheeeeats! didn't know i had it in me.
6:11 am
>> right thousand now we decide that every american household can receive a tax cut on the first $250,000 of their income. once again, leaders across the aisle are saying no. >> paul: well, it's not just republicans who are saying no to president obama's plan to raise taxes on upper incomes. 31 house democrats, most facing tough reelection fights this fall, have signed a letter urging house speaker nancy pelosi and house majority leader steny hoyer extending tax breaks for all income levels not just households making less than $250,000 a year. over in the senate, virginia's jim webb and connecticut's joe lieberman this week brought the total to five democrats calling for at least a temporary extension of the tax cuts across the board. so, steve, how wide is-- widespread is this democratic insurrection on taxes?
6:12 am
>> you know, paul, for the first time in my life i almost, i almost feel sorry for nancy pelosi. she's trying to put together this coalition, you know, last week stan greenberg, as you know, the democratic pollster, left the house democratic caucus and told the members, raise the taxes on the rich and cut taxes on middle class, what happened at that meeting according to my source all the members looked at stan greenberg and said he's not polling in my district. the truth is, cutting those taxes for everyone is what popular and i think the reason, paul, is that our message that we've been saying on the journal has really penetrated. if you raise taxes on the rich, that hurts the economy, hurts small businesses and most american workers say, wait a minute, a rich person is the one who scenes my paycheck. >> paul: kim, the president says that like stan greenberg, this politics works, all you do is raise taxes on the well-to-do, don't worry, nobody will care. so, that isn't flying in some
6:13 am
of these blue dog districts around the country and do you think it's because of the shape, the state of the economy, the iffy state of the economy? >> yeah, no, look, right now this is the worst possible time democrats could be dealing with the tax issue. 9.6% unemployment, there's talk of a double dip recession. the business community has turned against them and is making an issue out of this saying if you pass a new tax hike on us, on capital gains and dividends, you know, this is going to further impede our ability to grow the economy and so they're out there. this message is not flying. if this was such a winner, you know, the president would have all of his people on board wishing to do this, instead they're running the other way. >> paul: you know, dan, i mean, the best thing for the democratic party would be right now to extend those tax, those lower rates for two years, and you know, not make them-- i'd like to make them permanent, i think that would help the economy the most, but politically for them, take this off the table this year, extend it for two years and it will help them and by removing
6:14 am
the issue and would help the economy which would help them. why won't they do it? >> because the president of the united states doesn't want to do it, paul. >> paul: and why not? >> why not? remember the good old days when the liberals accused conservatives be wedded to conservative dogma, dogma? this idea of raising tax rates on the upper 1% or $250,000. >> paul: which doesn't seem rich in new jersey, new york, california, connecticut, maryland, virginia, among other places. >> this is something that barack obama ran on in the election. before the financial crisis hit. it's something he was talking about the first month of his presidency. he will not let it go. it's, you know, we've described it as class warfare and i think we're right that the economic uncertainty caused people to say, whoa, let's not fool around, let's just move ahead, let the tax cuts extend and we'll worry about it later. >> john boehner this week, the
6:15 am
republican leader got out on a limb when he said that maybe the-- he would vote for the tax, to extend the lower tax breaks only for the middle class, he was taken to the wood shed by his own members. was he not? >> well, yes, he was, because he walked right into the democratic crowd. this is one thing that they can hope to do with this debate is to go out there and say, look, you are holding the middle class hostage. if you, you demand that we extend all of these taxes and this could fail and it will be your fault and the middle class will come after you. and he seemed to be nerved out by that prospect. the reality is his party told him afterwards if the republicans can't run on universal tax relief right now, something that's popular, this year a good year for them, when are they going to? so they've since then recircled the carivans and trying to get back to the right positions. >> paul: steve, do you think we could get them extended for the lower tax rates for a
6:16 am
couple more years? >> i think there's so much disarray in the democratic caucus right now, paul, my bet is, democrats will do nothing, that they will go into this election basically because they don't want to, you know, keep the rates low for the rich people, they're going to go into this election promising essentially to raise taxes for everyone, not just people who make over $250,000, but people who make $50,000. i don't understand the logic of that, paul, i think they're running right into a buzz sawment they've had six years to fix the tax problem that's going to explode and they can't get their act together because of the class warfare ideology. >> if that's the case then republicans are going to be thrilled because they will have a tax issue this fall. >> to run on. >> paul: when we come back, he's picking another fight. new jersey governor chris christie rolls out his plan to save the state's troubled pension system and the public employee unions, well, they're not happy. >> you may not like this today, but ten years from now
6:17 am
when you have a pension to collect and health benefits to collect you're going to be looking for my address to send me a thank you note.
6:18 am
activia has delicious news for dessert lovers. often, the best part of a meal is the dessert. but sometimes after a busy day and a heavy greasy dinner... my system needs some tlc. now there is something new. introducing activia dessert.
6:19 am
rich, silky, smooth yogurt with desserty flavors like strawberry cheesecake, blueberry cheesecake, and peach cobbler. and because it's activia, it helps regulate my digestive system. mmm. works for me. ♪ activia new activia dessert.
6:20 am
>> what we theede to-- need to do is reform the system so there are pensions for folks when they retire. this isn't about promises made and kept. this is about special interest squeezing benefits out of the government and on to the taxpayers that we can no longer afford to pay and i'm not going to stand for it. >> paul: never shy for a reform fight. new jersey governor chris christie rolled out his plan to shore up that state's troubled pension system this week. and the public employee unions are howling. the plan would roll back a 9% pension benefit increase
6:21 am
granted in 2001. require most public workers to contribute 8 1/2% of their salaries toward their pensions, and have workers pay 30% of their health care premiums. the plan would also raise the retirement age to 65 for most employees. new jersey's current pension system is unfunded by a measley 46 billion dollars. assistant editorial page editor james freeman joins us with more. james, how good is this christie plan? >> pretty good if you're thinking about the finances of the state of new jersey. you mentioned 46 billion dollar unfunded. it's bigger 67 billion on the health side. >> paul: wow, 100 billion, he destroys most of the unfunded liability if he gets this plan through. >> paul: and most of these would just put the state employees in line with what the people in the private
6:22 am
business world already have to live with. >> if those people have jobs right now in private business. >> paul: if they have jobs, but the retirement age in new jersey right now is it what 60 for public employees? >> kind of depends, what you've been allowed to do there is retire relatively early and get great benefits and part of the plan is penalizing people for retiring early and making 65 the norm which it should be. >> paul: there's been no move to transfer employees to 401(k), define contribution systems, you and i and dan has, most people have, few private plans in the private sector. they're in the public sector, why didn't he make the reform. >> that's the reform you're looking for. he tried to do it in the spring and kind of a modest pension plan he designed, the legislature passed it and nipped around the edges, focused on new workers, but basically, after, after failing in that effort to get 401(k)'s in there, he kind of abandoned it.
6:23 am
>> paul: yeah, that's the structural reform, dan, i think would headache this system solve it going forward for 20, 30, 40 years. the problem with cutting pension benefits is that the next time you get a governor in who is sympathetic to the unions they could just restore those benefits. >> yeah, that's pretty much why we're in the trouble we're in. there is one distinction in the plan i think is worth pointing out. governor christie's proposal would apply to current state employees. >> paul: right. >> a lot of states have been doing reforms, arkansas, new york, even illinois, missouri and mississippi, but those are all for new hires. >> paul: right. >> the one state that's already done it for current workers is colorado. they are not getting a cost of leafing adjustment and raised the retirement agen auditors said doing it it's law if colorado they're pretty much on road to solvency. that's the crucial thing you've got to bite off going at the unions right now not 25 years from now. >> paul: and christie is doing that, clawing back the outrageous 9% increase given
6:24 am
in 2001. what's changed about the politics here, gentlemen? why is this different this time? >> why they're able to go so far? >> this was always fatal. arnold schwarzenegger tried to do something similar and got demolished by the unions. why is christie willing to that i can this on. >> he's got the legislature, but they have to face the voters next year. a level of fear, he's taken a strong stand and kind of fun for people in new jersey, used to our politicians being the laughingstock of the country frt he's kind of a national leader now and his approval rating has stayed above 50%, despite the-- the difficult cuts that he's had to make. >> i think the public knows there's no where to hide. california issued iou's to pay debts last year. >> you didn't get a tax return, you got an iou for a while. so the voters are ready to do it. >> the math is clear in new jersey, it doesn't work and that's to his benefit as he tries to reform. >> paul: all right, i think it's a very important, for the
6:25 am
national political system and reform in a lot of states, that christie be able to make this work. this work. we have to take one mor hey, you guys. want to try activia's great new taste? isn't this the yogurt that, you know... helps regulate your digestive system. trust me. it is beyond tasty. mmm. this is really good! new best tasting activia ever! ♪ activia host: could switching to geico realis a bird in the handre on worth 2 in the bush? appraiser: well you rarely see them in this good of shape. appraiser: for example the fingers are perfect. appraiser: the bird is in mint condition. appraiser: and i would say if this were to go to auction today, appraiser: conservatively it would be worth 2 in the bush. woman: really? appraiser: it's just beautiful, thank you so much for bringing it in.
6:26 am
woman: unbelievable anncr: geico. 15 minutes could save you 15% or more. did you know a problem in your heart can cause a stroke in your brain? it's true. an irregular heartbeat, called atrial fibrillation, or afib, can make a blood clot form, here, in your heart, that can break free and go straight to your brain where it can cause a serious stroke. having atrial fibrillation gives you a 5 times greater risk of stroke than if you didn't have it. strokes that are twice as likely to be deadly or severely disabling as other types of strokes. if you, or someone you care for, have atrial fibrillation, even if you're already taking medication, there are still important things you'll want to know. for a free interactive book call 1-877-580-afib, or log onto learn more about the connection between atrial fibrillation and strokes, and get advice on how to live with afib. and with this valuable information in your hand, talk to your doctor.
6:27 am
call 1-877-580-afib today.
6:28 am
>> time now for hits and misses of the week. dan, first to you. >> well, paul, potentially catastrophic miss for school reform. we've talked a lot on this program about the reports there, and in the mayoral primary, the mayor lost, the head of the city council who has been at odds with ms. reed, not clear he's going to reappoint her. and barack obama school reform as the center of his agenda and i think we could use a wink and a nod from the president in support of michelle reed right now in washington. >> paul: we sure could, james. >> a miss, paul, the bernie madoff scam was a tragedy for investors, but a windfall for the lawyers and specifically the trustee overseeing the liquidation, irving picard and
6:29 am
his law firm collected 35 million dollars for just four months of work recently. so, the argument is that he's not being paid by the victims, that it's the government essentially who pays him, all the investing public, but i think we can get a better deal than $100 million a year for the madoff liquidation. >> kim. >> a hit for gene taylor the first sitting democrat to sign a position to repeal obama care. a long time incumbent, but in a red district with a tough race and this is why it's important. i think some democrats are beginning to understand it's not enough to have just voted against the obama agenda, that they are going to have to step up and work with republicans to actually repeal a mixed part of it. so this is a big moment. >> the gene taylor, save my seat in congress act. okay. and remember, if you have your own hit or miss, please send it to us at that's it for th

The Journal Editorial Report
FOX News September 19, 2010 6:00am-6:30am EDT

News/Business. Paul Gigot discusses news, politics, society and finance. (CC) (Stereo)

TOPIC FREQUENCY Paul 8, Christie 5, New Jersey 4, Delaware 4, Jim Demint 4, Kim 4, California 3, Dan 3, Nancy Pelosi 3, Christine O'donnell 3, Chris Christie 3, New York 3, Stan Greenberg 3, Virginia 2, Wisconsin 2, Atrial Fibrillation 2, Barack Obama 2, Mmm 2, Steve 2, Mike 2
Network FOX News
Duration 00:30:00
Scanned in Annapolis, MD, USA
Source Comcast Cable
Tuner Port 1236
Video Codec mpeg2video
Audio Cocec mp2
Pixel width 720
Pixel height 480
Sponsor Internet Archive
Audio/Visual sound, color

disc Borrow a DVD of this show
info Stream Only
Uploaded by
TV Archive
on 9/19/2010